Monday, 20 August 2018

Crozier Column- End of the 2017-18 season


Image result for world cup scotland
As three of the last four nations Scotland have faced in friendly matches prepare for the biggest showpiece in world football- The World Cup, which is to be held in Russia in the middle of the month. Scotland face another barren summer of being frustrated armchair viewers dreaming of what might have been with an eye on our next venture of qualification for a major event. The latest failure led to a huge change in the national game in Scotland with the resignation/sacking of the national manager, taking with him the entire coaching staff, the SFA president also lost his job and the captain of the national side, the influential Scott Brown, also decided now was the time to retire from the international game.

Image result for alex mcleishAll of which left a huge mess for brave people to attempt to solve. Initially performance director Malky Mackay was given the nod to take the hotseat for the friendly against a Holland side also going through a transition. The result was not such a surprise, however the fact that Mackay wanted to thrust players into the international limelight was and it was a refreshing change at that- his changes in personnel and formation was a real eye-opener for Scotland and to come away with a narrow 1-0 defeat was harsh on the Scots who could so easily have come out with more. Mackay was soon to return to his day to day role and a returning Alex McLeish was given the role on a permanent basis to continue a job he left in November 2007 after only ten matches in charge. His first few months of his tenure really was to end the work of the previous tenure- four friendlies, not of which chosen by McLeish would be the starting point. These have been much discussed and largely criticised, particularly the latter two were Scotland travelled to Peru and Mexico which a much changed squad to see us defeated to two nations preparing for the World Cup. 

Image result for scotland vs peruLooking at those five friendlies in question in more detail we have to take some small comfort in that we have not been on the wrong end of a thumping in terms of the score. This is testament to the approach in the games and making it difficult for teams to earn their wins. Judging by the four games under McLeish it is clear he wants to build from the back. The defensive and midfield shape has stayed compact and narrow meaning that no threat was seen down the channels and shots were restricted to outside of the box. Against stronger opponents, like Mexico, we have to face that the opponents are very strong and at times caps have to be doffed and we have to face that sometimes we will play against stronger opponents

Image result for mexico vs scotlandPerhaps reading that four out of those five games were lost may raise eyebrows. However, when we look at the five friendly opponents all of the four opponents who beat us are above us, three of which are at this summer’s World Cup, and the solitary win was against a lower ranked side than we are- so not all doom and gloom as the media would make out. Looking at the latter two friendlies we took a second choice team, at best out to a different climate to play two friendlies against nations who are going to the World Cup and gave them a game, particularly the Mexicans in the second game. Those players who were given their chances certainly took them and I feel that they would have given Alex McLeish food for thought. Of the travelling party nine players were under the age of 23 and nine players made their first, and for some possibly their last, games for Scotland and for those players they did not disgrace themselves and that will live with them forever.

Therefore it comes as no surprise that my take on the future of our national side is largely different from the norm. I think for Scotland to have called up 45 players in the last five matches and for our starting eleven in our last friendly against Mexico to be made up of a team that between them had only played 28 times at this level is exciting for Scotland and did give a purpose for the friendlies – to try new tactics and to see whether players are good enough or have potential to be good enough for the national side going forward.

Image result for nations leagueI look at the future of the national side and I see real potential there for ending our barren run and making it to a major tournament sooner rather than later. Qualification for the European Championships has arguably never been easier with the introduction of the Nations League and looking at the nucleus of the squad that travelled to Peru and Mexico we have a youthful side that can develop together- what we need is two things in my opinion. Firstly a world class player- someone who can single handedly be a match winner. The Welsh have Bale and the Portuguese have Ronaldo and other than a handful of above average players they are a reliant on their world star. Secondly we need a goal scorer- successful Scotland sides have always had that as something to build from however other than Leigh Griffiths, who himself has had a stop start season, I struggle to see where we are going to get goals from.


Image result for scotland goalkeepersFrom the previous campaign and these friendlies Scotland under McLeish have some real depth and choices in some areas and weaknesses have been further exposed in others. Take the goalkeeping department for example – I think it is fair to say that we know who the two mainstays will be in the squad and that duo of Craig Gordon and Allan McGregor will be battling for the number 1 jersey. However three other keepers, Jon McLaughlin, Scott Bain and Jordan Archer, wait in the wings who all made their debuts during the Americans trip and will give selection headaches for the manager. If in the left back position we have a real depth of talent and resources we see the contradiction in the right back area with few examples to choose from – however the trip has shown that we have a diligent and dependable defender in Stephen O’Donnell, who may not thrill and excite but he will be a strong contender for the number 2 jersey.

Image result for scott mckennaIn the central positions it now appears that Scotland have options there. Towards the end of the Strachan era his central defensive choices would have been made up of Hanley, Martin, Greer and the mainstay of Charlie Mulgrew who looks like he will be the leader of the new look Scotland side. However now we see new emerging players coming through who have all performed relatively well. Scott McKenna has even captained the side in that time so coming from an unknown to skippering the side is an amazing rise, Jack Hendry has also shown ability in his friendly caps, add to that Christophe Berra who has not appeared under McLeish yet and his club team mate John Souttar it is clear that we have great options in that area of the park.

Image result for dylan mcgeouchOne of the biggest issues I feel Scotland will face going forward, and these friendly fixtures only highlighted this further, is the lack of a midfield anchor since the retirement of Scott Brown. We look like we long for a player who is naturally more defensive, who can sit in front of a back four, break up play and intercept balls. Those players tried in that area did not look comfortable doing this. Kenny McLean looked out of his depth and Dylan McGeouch wanted the ball and looked like he wanted to create but struggled to break up attacking play from opponents. An option for the future touted is Allan Campbell, who is with the Under-21 side currently and looks a prospect but maybe that step up is too soon for now.

Image result for scott mctominayRetention of the ball was another area of concern for the Scots in the friendly matches. Again a lot of combinations and individuals were trialled there. McLean, McGeouch and Scott McTominay all came in with a lot of praise around their abilities to be techinically proficient and retain the ball however in the friendly matches this didn’t look the case. If we look at some of the opposing players you could see clear differences between the line ups in that Scotland lacked fluidity in the midfield and were very rigid to role – this is likely to change in the Nations League as we welcome back more experience players and the opposition’s quality decrease marginally also.

Image result for leigh griffithsLooking at the attacking side of the friendlies we had some areas of development – Matt Phillips has shown he can lead the line on his own really well and did so against Hungary and Peru, Oli McBurnie, although raw, looks like he has potential to be on the international scene for some years to come. Johnny Russell was without doubt the stand out performer against Mexico and Lewis Morgan’s cameos in both his appearances gives hope for him personally and the national side. However more so than that it shows that our goal threat is depleted massively without Leigh Griffiths leading the line.

Image result for hampden parkAlthough the world of football is gearing up for the World Cup, us Scotland fans can only dream of making another major appearance and we will be watching but with a focus on the Nations League where hopefully we will be able to be a success and end our barren run. I feel Alex McLeish will need to ensure we hit the ground running so we can get a real feel good factor back into our national game. The Costa Rica friendly, the only home one of the five, was a real example of where it needs to be found because a poor attendance of 20,000 inside Hampden made it feel very empty and quiet and we know that when it is full the atmosphere is spectacular and to have that back would be incredible because I genuinely feel that the future is looking bright for the national side.

Before we look to far forwards at the end of all football years/campaigns awards are given out (no matter how successful the team have been) so this is my nod to that as a Scotland fan for the last season.

Image result for andrew robertson scotlandPlayer of the Year – as we have discussed in this column we have used a lot of players in this transitional period between the end of Strachan’s reign and the beginning of McLeish’s so choosing a Player of the Year is very tricky. However for me my player of the year is Andrew Robertson. He has improved so much from the player who was released from Celtic as a youth player to play for Queens Park, then moving to Dundee United before moving to Liverpool where he has had a tremendous first season and played in a Champions League final. In a Scotland shirt he has impressed whenever he has played both defensively but as an attacking outlet on the left hand side. He has a tremendous work rate, excellent engine and when he has played has been involved for Scotland has been named Man of the Match in matches and generally shows he plays at a higher level than the majority of his countrymen. A tremendous player and as we move into the next campaign we are all hopeful this continues.  

Image result for scott mckenna scotland

Young player of the Year – this is an award that could go to a few younger players who have come in and made an impression in the senior ranks but the winner of the award is someone who has come into the fold later in the season and has impressed massively and gives hope for Scotland defensively moving forward. Scott McKenna has been simply superb all last season for Aberdeen and has made four appearances for Scotland and in doing so played well personally and looked assured and moved himself into pole position as one of the two central defenders for Scotland moving into the next campaign. He has great strength both in the air and on the ground.



Image result for anthony ralston scotland

One to watch – the criteria for this award was someone who has not been involved in the National senior squad but someone who has potential to be involved at some point in the next campaign. For this reason I have given this to Anthony Ralston who is a Celtic right back and performed very well at the Toulon tournament in the summer and is someone who has developed well at Celtic and on loan at Dundee United. I am hoping that he gets another loan move this season that would give him game time to impress Alex McLeish as he could fulfil a position in the team in an area that is a problematic area for the team.


Image result for andrew robertson goal vs lithuaniaGoal of the Year – Nine goals were scored in the last ‘season’ but the best goal for me has to go to Andrew Robertson in the impressive 3-0 win away to Lithuania. Having gone 1-0 up through Stuart Armstrong, Robertson scored a wonder goal after a mazy run down the left hand side and a ball cut back to the edge of the box. The ball was then played a short distance of around three yards to on oncoming Robertson who took a touch with his left foot before he placed the ball into to the roof of the net an incredible strike from around 20 yards out helping Scotland cap one of the best victories and moments in the last campaign

Image result for tartan army celebratingChampagne moment of the Year – the campaign was ended in disappointment ultimately however along the way there were some moments that brought huge levels of optimism and for me the this was at its peak, and therefore the Champagne moment of last season was when we beat Slovakia at Hampden Park leaving us a victory away from a realistic playoff place for the World Cup. The campaign on the whole was very much a slow burner and that result brought back a lot of enthusiasm and expectation to the national game

Image result for tartan army heartbrokenFlat beer moment of the Year – not many to choose from last season but the obvious one was the last game of the campaign when a victory would have guaranteed a playoff spot we ultimately ended in bitter disappointment with a draw away in Slovenia. This result in isolation was not a bad one or a terrible result but the build up leading to this game was stratospheric and a welcome return for Scottish football and the Tartan Army.

So now to look forward to the Nations Cup and let’s hope that this campaign ends in some success for the long suffering Scottish fans.

Future blogs will involve a Top 40 each month of all of the eligible players who could play for Scotland selected based on form, a monthly column from myself on around an area to do with the National side, analysis of squads, news, focus on opponents, head to heads, picking starting elevens, discussing tactics and predictions and match reports. 

No comments:

Post a Comment