Sunday, 2 June 2019

The Future Forty


The Future Forty
It is a debate that seems to crop up whenever we are on the wrong end of a humbling defeat or when the autopsy of a qualification campaign is being undertaken by the media and football fans alike. Do Scotland have the players and quality at their disposal to take them to a major footballing tournament? Our new manager has expressed that he feels we have the players to do that before he took the job. My views on it are that we certainly have. If you look at the last European Championships for example – I would argue that Scotland have as good a squad as Northern Ireland and Albania, who both made the event.
Obviously with the appointment of Steve Clarke to the Scotland role it will be down to him to use the resources at this disposal to end the suffering of the Tartan Army using the players that we have already established in the squad and adding some new players into the regime to find a winning formula.
Below is a list of forty players who are eligible to play for Scotland that are, as yet uncapped. I have not chosen players who may be eligible through parental/grandparent links that have not committed to Scotland meaning that Che Adams and Jed Steer have been omitted from this list.

1 – David Turnbull (aged 19, current club – Motherwell)
Young midfielder who has made a huge impression in the SPL this season. Twelve goals for his club in his first full season as a senior professional, contributed to 37% of his clubs goals and without his goals his team would have been 15 points worse off. Add to that the record for best shooting accuracy in the league and comparisons to Michael Ballack – it is a matter of when and not if he is involved with Scotland. Undoubtedly will attract interest of big clubs – the key for him is playing at this stage.
11 – Stevie Mallan (aged 23, current club – Hibernian)
Mallan first burst onto the scene with St Mirren where his performances and goals earned him a move to Championship club Barnsley. Although his move did not necessarily work out for him, he has found his feet again with Hibernian. At the Edinburgh club he has recaptured his creativity, especially with set plays and this has helped his side to a good finish in the league and his individual performances have caught the eye. One to keep watch over for sure.
21 – Anthony Ralston (aged 20, current club – Celtic)
Although Ralston has not played a lot of senior football, he plays in a position where Scotland have a real lack of options. Last season he spent time on loan at Dundee United and that alongside training and being involved at Celtic has shown that he is deemed good enough showing he is one to keep an eye on. He has tasted Champions League football and has been involved more in match day squads. Next season will be a real make or break one for him.
31 – Greg Doherty (aged 22, current club – Rangers)
He started his career at Hamilton where he played just shy of 100 games. His performances and potential led to a move to Rangers where spent the first season finding first team football hard to come across. This season he has been on loan in England with League One side Shrewsbury Town where he ended the season winning the player of the year. Rumours of an allegiance switch to Ireland have been prominent but could do a job for Scotland if he can get regular football
2 – John Fleck (aged 27, current club - Sheffield United)
The former Rangers midfielder has had a tremendous season in helping his club side win promotion back to the Premier League. Toward the end of Alex McLeish’s reign he became a squad regular but did not show enough for the then manager to earn his first cap. Fleck is a player who has shown he is not afraid to break up play and keep possession which is something that we need to find in our teams. He would come into this squad with great confidence and form and I would be surprised if he were left out of the first squad under Clarke
12 – Ryan Gauld (aged 23, current club – Sporting Lisbon)
Dubbed ‘mini Messi’ he had been the talk of Scottish football and had been touted for a bright future for Scotland since an early age. At Dundee United he burst onto their scene and this secured a lucrative move to Portugal. Since the move his career has stunted a lot and now needs to ensure he is playing regular football to make sure that his potential is fulfilled. He has tried to address that by returning for a loan spell at Hibernian, however, he has found game time hard to come by due to injuries but has talent for certain.
22 – Zander Clark (aged 26, current club – St Johnstone)
Another keeper who is a contender to be included in upcoming squads due to the lack of depth. Like a lot of Scottish players he has had to earn his stripes with his club by going out on loan- but now he is very much the first choice keeper at the Perth club. During this season he played every game up until February when he picked up an injury. During that spell in the team he was touted for a Scotland call-up when he was an integral part of his club keeping five consecutive clean sheets. This has certainly been the best season of his career in terms of appearances and could be in the thoughts of the Scotland management team.
32 – Charlie Gilmour (aged 20, current club – Arsenal)
Another player who has been spoken about as a potential Scotland star without any real senior footballing experience. He is a ball winning midfielder who keeps possession well and has an eye to create chances with an excellent range of passing. Gilmour has played all through the Scotland teams from Under 15 – 19 level and has also played for England at Under 16 and 17 level. He has only appeared on two occasions for Arsenal in the Europa League and looks set to leave the club during the summer. He needs to find a club where he can play regularly in order to fulfil his potential as a player.
3 – Lewis Ferguson (aged 19, current club – Aberdeen)
Another youngster who has impressed massively in his breakthrough season. He has shown that he is a big game player and always makes a mark on matches, not always necessarily in a positive manner. He first came to prominence when he scored for his club in a Europa League qualification game with an overhead kick. He followed that up with a goal in the Scottish League Cup Semi Final – with excellent performances all season. Not only does he score goals, he is not afraid to break up play. He is certainly not fazed by occasions – one for the Tartan Army to get excited about for sure.
13 – Liam Lindsay (aged 23, current club – Barnsley)
Over the last few years whenever squads have been announced Liam Lindsay’s name has always been discussed as someone who should be involved. Over his first years as a professional he impressed at Partick and in his last season with the club was the only player, not at Aberdeen or Celtic to be named in the team of the season. His time in England has been very successful, he has become a first team regular with Barnsley and will be playing Championship football with them next season giving him more chance to improve as a player and impress watching Scotland scouts.
23 – Billy Gilmour (aged 17, current club – Chelsea)
Considering this is a young lad who has not played a single minute of senior football, to have him in this list, or to be so prominent on it is quite remarkable. Gilmour has played at all levels up to and including Under 21. During his development at Rangers he was scouted by Chelsea who paid a reported half a million for him. He is a player who is very skilful on the ball and is continuing to build on that with his current club. Certainly one to keep an eye out for and his development over the next few seasons.

33 – Ryan Porteous (aged 20, current club – Hibernian)
Porteous is a player who has had to bide his time to get games at Hibs and when he has had a run in the team this has been hit by untimely injury. In the 2017-18 season he was an unused substitute on 30 occasions only making six appearances in the league. In his second season he appeared a lot more but was hit by an injury in the January causing him to miss the rest of the season. This term he has played 23 times and if he can sustain fitness and get a good run in the team then he could well find Scotland call-ups are not too far away for him as he has looked impressive in games I have watched.
4 – Greg Taylor (aged 21, current club – Kilmarnock)
In an era without Kieran Tierney and Andrew Robertson he would be a prospect for Scotland for sure. However, when you have two of the best left backs in European football ahead of you it will be hard to amass caps no matter how good you are. Having said that he has been very dependable and solid for his club all season and Steve Clarke obviously knows him well enough to ultimately determine whether he is good enough. With Tierney set to miss the qualifiers he could find himself in the squad for the upcoming double header.
.
14 – Mikey Johnston (aged 20, current club – Celtic)
Having made his debut for Celtic in 2017, he has had to wait for his chance to make a breakthrough. This season however, he has been given a lot more chance to impress. On the whole he has done this. Scoring on five occasions this season and starting the Scottish Cup he has really given his manager food for thought in terms of becoming a first team regular. Either way he has proven that he is good enough for Celtic and adds depth to their squad. He is versatile playing this season both as a winger and a striker, he could become a regular face in the Scotland set-up.
24 – Fraser Hornby (aged 19, current club – Everton)
Another player mentioned in the list who has not established himself at club level but making waves in the Scottish game. Hornby has only tasted 82 minutes of senior football, however it is his record at Under 21 level that is getting people excited. With six goals in eight appearances he is currently tied third in the all-time goal scorers at that level. The next couple of seasons will be key to his development and he may need to go out on loan to get game. Scotland fans will be keeping a keen eye on his development at Everton as we are longing for a goal scorer at senior level.
34 – Oli Shaw (aged 21, current club – Hibernian)
Young striker at Hibernian who is beginning to find more senior football and is performing well with the Under 21’s. Shaw started off by being involved in the youth team and making rare appearances for the Edinburgh club before going on loan and scoring goals for Stenhousemuir. From the loan spell he has begun to find senior football for his club. He has scored ten times in forty league appearances. This season has been a breakthrough for him as he has made 35 appearances and found the net on 7 times. One to keep an eye on over the next few years.
5 – Liam Cooper (aged 27, current club – Leeds United)
Hugely surprising that he has not been capped by Scotland having flirted with call-ups over recent years. Cooper is a solid, usually dependable, centre half who has captained his club over the last two seasons. He has finished the season being named in the Championship team of the year and according to media speculation has held positive talks with Steve Clarke. Don’t be surprised to see him in the squad for the Cyprus and Belgium matches. Having seen him at club level I certainly feel he is good enough to be involved and has all the attributes to adapt at a higher level.

15 – Ross McCrorie (aged 21, current club – Rangers)
McCrorie is the current Under 21 captain and has shown for both club and country that he has versatility that could assist in future squads. His first league appearance for his club was an Old Firm derby and showed in that game, as well as others, that he can handle the big occasion. Originally he was deployed as a centre half but has played more recently as a defensive midfielder – both are positions that Scotland have looked short in over recent times. He has played over thirty games for his club this season and has impressed and may not be far away from making that transition to the main squad.

25 – Greg Stewart (aged 29, current club – Birmingham)
Although he is close to the prime years of his career, he could be an answer for Scotland. Stewart initially made his breakthrough with Dundee where his performances and more importantly his goals secured him a move to Birmingham City. Through lack of goals he quickly became surplus to requirements. A move back home at Kilmarnock was successful where he scored eight times in sixteen matches. A further loan move to Aberdeen for the second half of the season was less than prolific – but Rangers have signed the striker for next season – if he rediscovers some form there a call-up would not be far away.
35 – Liam Henderson (aged 23, current club – Hellas Verona)
Another of the rare breed of Scotsmen that go abroad in recent years and make a success of it. Henderson spent his first five years as a professional at Celtic, making loan moves to Rosenberg and Hibernian in that time. He did make around 30 appearances for Celtic, including in Cup Finals and in Europe, before deciding on moving to Italy, first to Bari and now with Verona – where he has been praised for his work rate and versatility, which would appeal for clubs and at national level. He has played for Scotland at youth levels up to Under 21 level and I am sure that his progress is being monitored by the Scottish FA.
6 – Eamonn Brophy (aged 23, current club – Kilmarnock)
Over the last twelve months, Brophy has shown his credentials by initially displacing rivals in the starting eleven to get club football and then scoring goals for his club – in big games. It is no secret that Scotland need a goal scorer and under McLeish different strikers have been looked at without much success. Having played under Clarke and media speculation that he is in the thoughts of the Scotland manager, he could be called up for the senior side for the Cyprus and Belgium matches. 
16 – Mikey Devlin (aged 25, current club – Aberdeen)
Devlin is a player who has been included in recent Scotland squads but as yet has been capped at senior level. Having spent time on loan in lower league football in Scotland he finally became a first team regular with Hamilton clocking up over 100 games. His debut season with Aberdeen has been hit somewhat by injury but has definitely been in the thoughts of the previous Scottish management team and may not be too far away from the thoughts of Steve Clarke, especially if he can get a run of games and put injury nightmares behind him.
26 – Connor McLennan (aged 19, current club – Aberdeen)
A young player who has been out on loan to clubs in Scotland but is now very much part of Aberdeen’s first team plans. This season he has been involved in most match day squads and came on during the League Cup final. Since that appearance in December he has played more regularly and impressed both as a wide player and as the main striking option. Again, with age on his side, he may not be included at the moment but would not be too far away from the thoughts of the Scottish set up, especially if he stays involved at Under 21 level.
36 – Richard Tait (aged 29, current club – Motherwell)
At the age of 29 he is someone who may have missed his chance to pull on a Scotland shirt, however with a lack of options at right back he may still get a chance. His journey to regular Motherwell right back has taken him to such glamour as Curzon Ashton and Tamworth but this season has been an ever present for Motherwell and no other player has played more than him for his club this season. Due to the lack of right sided defensive options and him being such a dependable player he could be called upon.
7 – Stuart Findlay (aged 23, current club – Kilmarnock)
Another player who has been managed by Steve Clarke and has was included in the previous Scotland squad under Alex McLeish as a late call up for Charlie Mulgrew. Findlay started his career at Celtic and moved to Newcastle, showing his undoubted ability – although he did not play for either club he has managed to find his feet at Kilmarnock. He has played with the Under 21’s and been a regular for them and has impressed this season at club level. Obviously been in the thoughts of the Scotland national side and could find himself involved under Clarke.
17 – Liam Kelly (aged 23, current club – Livingston)
With the retirement of Allan McGregor and Craig Gordon not getting game time – the opportunity to become the Scottish first choice goalkeeper has opened up. This season in particular Kelly has impressed for his club and has kept a lot of clean sheets and made a lot of saves therefore impressing plaudits. He was called into the last squad of Alex McLeish as a replacement but is clearly on the Scottish radar. With Steve Clarke having seen him on a few occasions this season I would not be surprised to see him named in the squad for the Cyprus and Belgium matches.
27 – Ewan Henderson (aged 19, current club – Celtic)
Ewan Henderson, like his older brother Liam, has come through the system at Celtic. Although older brother has moved on Ewan is pressing to be involved more. This season he has played five first team matches and on his full league debut he was named Man of the Match. He has played for Scotland at Under 17 and 19 level and it may be too soon for such a promotion into the senior squad but is without doubt one to keep an eye on. Like his older brother may need to move on, either on loan or permanently to gain experience. 
37 – Jason Kerr (aged 22, current club – St Johnstone)
With over 100 senior appearances and caps at Under 21 level, Kerr could be another candidate to make the step up to the senior squad. Another player who has had to go out on loan to smaller clubs in Scotland, having had spells at East Fife and Queens of the South, he has now cemented his place in the St Johnstone defence having played 44 times in all competitions this season, making him the clubs most appeared player. He has caught the eye this season and with another season like the one he has just had and he could appear in the Scotland squad moving forward.
8 – Craig Halkett (aged 23, current club – Livingston)
Having started his career at Rangers he was deemed surplus to requirements there but has not let this set back finish him. His move to Livingston has been a great one for him as he has impressed all season for a club tipped for a quick return to the Championship. He has won a lot of fans from pundits and supporters this season and has appeared in a lot of pundit’s teams of the season. As a centre half he would find some competition in starting games and earning caps – however I think he is a contender to be included in the next squad.
18 – Murray Wallace (aged 26, current club – Millwall)
Central defender Murray Wallace is quietly impressing Scottish football fans without making huge waves. During his spell in England he has been at Huddersfield and Scunthorpe but this season he really caught the eye during his clubs FA Cup run where he impressed against stronger opponents. He has spent this season fighting his way into the starting eleven with his club where he is a regular first choice now. Looking at the options and players who have been experimented with in that position he could be another name that is looked at under the new regime.
28 – Andy Halliday (aged 27, current club – Rangers)
Another player who that surprises me in that he has not been called up and capped before now and perhaps he may get overlooked now with younger players coming through. That being said Halliday has become somewhat of a Renaissance Man with Rangers. This term has been his best club return for a while having played 35 games for his club. He is one who can handle the big occasion and if he continues to play regularly and impress in doing so he may not be too far away from the thoughts of Steve Clarke at all.
38 – Aaron Hickey (aged 19, current club – Heart of Midlothian)
Unless you are a Hearts fan, Hickey would be an unknown. That was until he was given a surprise start in this season’s Cup Final – his first for the club. Up until that point he had only made two substitute appearances for the club. In the Cup Final he did not look out of place and performed well in the Hearts midfield. At 19, he has a bright future ahead of him and will probably be looking at adding to his caps at different age levels. So far he has been capped at U17 level only. One to keep an eye out for his development.
9 – Jack Harper (aged 23, current club – Malaga)
There are not many young Scottish players who not only make the move abroad, but are also relatively successful with it. Harper is a product of Real Madrid so has shown he has undoubted ability. Although he did not make the cut at Real, he has moved to Malaga where he has bided his time in their B team and is now playing regularly for their first team. This season he has four goals from over twenty games- one on the Scottish radar for sure.

19 – Allan Campbell (aged 20, current club – Motherwell)
Campbell first caught my eye when he played in the Toulon tournament last season and his no-nonsense style of football impressed me. His work rate was admirable, full of tenacity and someone who breaks play and keeps the ball – he reminds me of a Scott Brown type player. Considering his relative young age for him to have played over 70 games for his club is testament to how good a player he is. Perhaps a little early to be included is could be a matter of time until he is.
29 – Glenn Middleton (aged 19, current club – Rangers)
Another youngster, who for me is showing that we have a lot of potential coming through and players to be excited about. This season Middleton has been given a lot of game time under his manager, who is a player who knows a bit about midfielders. He is obviously well thought of at his club as he has recently signed a five year deal and is very much in the Scottish system having been capped up to and included the Under 21 squad. Certainly one for the next few campaigns.
39 – Harvey St Clair (aged 20, current club – Venezia)
Youngster Harvey St Clair started his career at Chelsea where he spent twelve years before moving on to Venezia in Serie B in Italy. In his debut season he has played 14 games and struggled to make a real impact. He has, however, appeared for Scotland from Under 17 level through to the 21’s. His first impressions to the Scotland fans at the Toulon tournament of 2018 where he played well in helping Scotland finish fourth. Another player who may need to look at increasing his game time to force involvement for the senior squad.
10 – Jake Hastie (aged 20, current club – Motherwell)
Although his club team mate David Turnbull has earned a lot of plaudits this year it is Hastie that has engineered a move to a ‘bigger’ club when he signed a pre-contract deal with Rangers. This season he has shown that he is a tricky wide midfielder who has little fear and has performed well in the big games for his club. Over recent games he has shown more of an end product by making more assists and scoring goals. Under Steven Gerrard and Gary McAllister he has a huge chance to develop his game, hopefully not at the risk of losing vital game time. Certainly has a huge future ahead of him.
20 – Harry Cochrane (aged 18, current club – Hearts)
I have been very impressed with how Cochrane has adapted to senior football at an early age. He has shown no nerves and always performed admirably. Arguably best known for scoring the first goal in his clubs demolition of Celtic to end their unbeaten run of 69 matches, when he was sixteen years old. He has struggled somewhat this season due to injury but returned for the end of the season and was involved in some of his clubs matches but did not make the starting eleven or appear for his club in the Cup final. I am sure he will be back next season and will add a headache to Clarke sooner rather than later.
30 – Bruce Anderson (aged 20, current club – Aberdeen)
Anderson is certainly one to keep an eye on and I admire the route he is taking to be successful at the highest level. He burst onto the radar of Scottish fans when he scored on his debut against Rangers and has followed that up with another senior goal in the ten appearances he has made for Aberdeen. Not content with lacking first team football he has been out on loan at Elgin and latterly Dunfermline where he has found the net prolifically. Whether he makes the break through with Aberdeen remains to be seen but he is showing signs that he is a good striking option. Next season is a pivotal one for him.
40 – Lawrence Shankland (aged 23, current club Ayr United)
Not often does a player who is playing for Ayr get mentioned as a potential Scotland international but he is a player who is clearly playing at a level that is below his ability. At his current club his record stands at 50 goals from 61 appearances which is a phenomenal return. He is out of contract with the Championship side and will be a target for a lot of clubs. What is key for him is finding a club where he can continue to play and develop because he clearly knows where the goal is. Two goals for Scotland U21 from two games also backs that up.

Thursday, 16 May 2019

We all think we know who it will be...but who are the other candidates for the top job


Ten Scotland Managerial candidates that may be in line for the top job

It has been just under a month since Alex McLeish was ‘relieved’ of this duties as Scotland manager and since then a lot of names and speculation have been cast over the next man for the job. In seemingly characteristic fashion the SFA have allowed this to happen and have dithered around who the next boss will be. However over the last two days the resolution has begun with strong rumours of an appointment being made tomorrow. It was revealed around two and a half weeks ago that a ‘shortlist’ had been discussed and finalised…with that in mind I am not sure what has taken so long. Let’s hope that the time taken is to ensure the right man is selected. Below, this article focuses on the Top 10 candidates, in order, on who I would be approaching as Scotland manager.


Steve Clarke – currently the nation’s choice it seems. He has spent a lot of time working in good managerial teams with Jose Mourinho, Kenny Dalglish and Avram Grant. He then took on the top job of West Bromwich Albion and spent a full season and a third of a season in charge their in the Premier League where he managed to stabalise the team as an established top flight team.  Following his spell at West Bromwich he had an ill-feted stint at Reading before assisting at Aston Villa. It is at Kilmarnock, where he has been since October 2017 that has caught the eye of clubs and made him a strong candidate for Scotland. At the time of publishing this he is the bookies favourite with odds as low as 1/10 for him to land the job.


Pros – he has the support of a lot of Scotland fans and media alike. This is because he has taken a side with limited resources and made them a difficult team to beat and raised their expectations and standards in the process. Clarke took over with Kilmarnock languishing near the foot of the table and has taken them to being on the verge of European football. His contract runs until the end of the season and he has not refused to directly rule out the job when questioned.

Cons – he has repeatedly stated that Kilmarnock was not a forever job as he has family commitments in London and is missing his grandchildren for example – would this job help or hinder that? Attraction from clubs in England could sway him back down where he would be involved every day in the running of a club. More recently his condemnation of a referee in a domestic game may not have gone down too well and may be ill-timed if he has desired on the top job in Scotland.


Derek McInnes – initially a stong candidate in the eyes of the supporters and media along with the bookmakers but all three of those listed have cooled a little on him. Having started his managerial career at St Johnstone where he guided them to the Premiership before leaving for an unsuccessful spell in England with Bristol City. It is in his current job at Aberdeen where he has really made a name for himself. In his six year spell to date he has won the League Cup, finished runners up on three occasions, guided the club back into Europe and generally made Aberdeen a very good and stable side.

Pros – he has transformed a side from being a mid-table mediocre side into regular challengers to Celtic for silverware in Scotland. His teams are usually well organised and is not afraid to turn to youth, an area where Scotland have a lot of potential players coming through.. He has recently stated that the plan is to manage Scotland at some point in his career…

Cons - …that may not be now. He is still deemed a young manager and perhaps is not interested in the Scotland job at the moment, although he is considered a strong candidate, his vice chairman has stated that he would not accept the job yet With the plans for a new stadium and training facilities at Aberdeen on the horizon, he could be tempted to stay longer in order to close the gap on the Old Firm more if he possibly can.


David Moyes – a manager who has been touted for the Scotland job since it became vacant and although perhaps not seen as one of the fans choices his credentials and experiences are hard to match again the other serious candidates for the position. At the age of 22 he had started his route into coaching by taking coaching badges and his first job came at Preston where he initially saved them from relegation within two season they had been promoted and narrowly missed out on a second promotion. He then moved on to Everton, where he enjoyed the most success as a manager and helped him raise his profile. After eleven years at one club, leading them to a fourth place finish and European football both in Champions League qualification and Europa League, he took on what now seems to have been the poison chalice of taking over from fellow Scotsman Sir Alex Ferguson at Manchester United. Although his record at the time was not the most impressive and certainly did not match his predecessor in any way, within 18 months he was sacked. This move now looks hasty and the next managers all have worse or comparable records to Sir Alex. His more recent record does not look good on his CV – sacked by Real Sociedad and resigned from both Sunderland and West Ham with poor win records at all three clubs – since then he has been out of work but with his experiences could be a good fit. 

Pros – a lot of experience in many different aspects of football – he has managed elite players, managed abroad and in European club competition. He has the respect of professional footballers and is someone who a lot of the ‘stay away’ players may come and play for (a huge barrier to McLeish’s tenure). His sides are usually difficult to beat and organises his teams very well. He is currently out of a job so compensation would not be an issue for the frugal SFA.

Cons – recently, like other candidates mentioned, he has said that he would prefer a move back to club football and rumours of him managing Celtic do not appear to be going away. Having managed big clubs in England I am not sure his wage demands would be something that the SFA would be prepared to meet either. His recent managerial record is also not one that would inspire the nation potentially and his style of football may make Scotland even more difficult to watch.


Neil Lennon – Lennon has spent the majority of his managerial career in Scotland and has enjoyed a lot of his personal successes there. Initially he was appointed as Celtic reserve’s team but following a successful caretaker role he was given the first team managers job. During his four years at the club he led the Glasgow side to the Scottish Cup twice and the League on three occasions. At the end of four years he moved to Bolton where he spent a frustrating season and a half where they battled relegation and suffered with cash problems. His next job was back in Scotland, with Hibernian. During his time there he led them to promotion to the Scottish Premier League and to Europa League football. He was suspended in January 2019 and left the club by mutual consent. Less than a month later he was back as interim manager of Celtic where he has overseen the club win the league, Scottish League Cup and are a game away from the treble Treble. Know the Scottish game well and would be a strong candidate.

Pros – his experience and successes in the Scottish game is probably paramount to the other names mentioned. His current contract with Celtic runs until the end of the season with no word yet on an extension or whether he will even be retained means that he could be a free agent in time prior to the next European Championship qualifying matches. He has managed a lot of good players in his time and has made Celtic in his time there and Hibernian good sides and his knowledge of Scottish football and players is very strong also.

Cons - whether Celtic sign him or not he will be a man in demand and he will have options. Lennon will need to consider whether the day to day running of club football can be substituted for international management. My general feeling is that he would be lured to the day to day work somewhere, most probably in England. His involvement with Celtic and Hibernian may make him someone who struggles to win over all supporters.


Scot Gemmill – perhaps not the first name that sprung to people’s minds when choosing a Scotland manager but it would be a move that follows the successes of England and Germany with appointing within (both Gareth Southgate and Joachim Low were working at international level before landing the top job). Although his managerial experience has been limited by only managing Scotland at Under 17 and 21 level. He is well respected by the SFA and could be ready for the job if the SFA do gamble on him.

Pros – biggest pro for Scot Gemmill is that he is in the system and on the pay role currently. He knows what his employers are like and has a good working relationship with them. Looking enviably at relative successes England have had it is clear that like Southgate, Gemmill knows the players available very well having worked within the system since 2014. He is a young manager with fresh ideas and Scotland have also previously appointed within when Craig Brown and Andy Roxburgh were given the job.

Cons – I think the next Scotland appointment is one that could either help or hinder the perception of the SFA amongst Scotland supporters. Over recent history they have failed to be seen in a positive light and a lot of the anger from the San Marino game was aimed at them. Addressing this would be to perhaps give in to public demand a bit and appoint one of the front runners. I am not sure Gemmill’s appointment would be well supported amongst Scotland fans and he would already be on the back foot trying to win them over. His lack of experience outside the Scotland system may also go against him as he doesn’t have the experience of dealing with players and clubs like he would have to with the job in question.



Malky Mackay – again, another name that has immediately been linked with the job and has led Scotland on a caretaker basis. He started his career when he took on the Watford job toward the end of the 2008-09 season. He then completed the following season in the Championship before Cardiff offered him a three year deal after compensation for his services were agreed. His spell there was very successful with a League Cup final and promotion to the Premier League. In the December of the following season he had been sacked by the club. Following his sacked alleged leaked messages and communication sent from Mackay came to the forefront which were homophobic, sexist and racist- it meant his reputation had been tarnished. His next appointment at Wigan was met with huge opposition and within five months he was dismissed – a very controversial choice if he were to be given the Scotland job.

Pros – he is another potential candidate who is employed by the SFA at the moment so understands how they work as employers. He has tasted international management, albeit it briefly, when he took charge of Scotland in a friendly match against Holland prior to Alex McLeish’s appointment. He would be a person who understands the talent pool that is available for Scotland as current performance director.

Cons – his departure from Cardiff has had damaging effects to his career and if he were to be given the Scotland national team role it would be very controversial and I am not sure the SFA would want to have to deal with the fallout from it. With a lack of coaching and management over the last few years and how quickly the game evolves perhaps this job would also be a leap too far.


Jack Ross – would be a real fairytale for the current Sunderland manager. Having played his football predominantly in Scotland and not achieving full honours as a player (capped at B level) to go onto take the national team job would be testament to his work ethic. Having been a coach and interim manager at Dumbarton he moved onto the Hearts coaching team but his first management role was at Alloa where he impressed, his tenure there lead to St Mirren calling where he stabilised the club in the Championship before getting the Paisley club promotion to the Scottish Premier League. In May 2018 he was given permission to talk to Sunderland where he has led them to a playoff place in League One. His successes at St Mirren and Hearts, as well as being a younger manager with fresh ideas have led him to be considered a candidate for Scotland. 

Pros – young, fresh manager with new coaching ideas (both Strachan and McLeish were criticised for being ‘out of touch’. He has been very open and honest and stated that he wants to manage Scotland at some point in his career.

Cons – that point in his career may not be now. He has stated recently that he has unfinished business at Sunderland and the draw of them being in the Championship (if they negotiate the playoffs) may be too difficult to turn down. I think he is a definite candidate for the job but would need others to decline it first.



Slavan Bilic – around two/three weeks ago speculation was high around Bilic, however this seems to have cooled. His first management involvement was with his national team during Euro 2008 qualification he led Croatia to topping their group which included England. At the tournament itself. Having failed to qualify for the World Cup in 2010 they did qualify for the European Championships in 2012 in which they were drawn in a tough group and did not make it out of the group stage – this led to his departure and he is held in high esteem within Croatia for his achievements. Subsequent appointments have not gone as well, Lokomotiv Moscow sacked him after 18 months with his tenure seeing the side finish in their worst league position. A short spell in Turkey with Besiktas did not end much better. West Ham was his next move and he performed very well and showed why he was seen to be a good manager – West Ham finished the 2007-08 season in 7th and broke a lot of club records in doing so helping them qualify for Europe. 2016-17 the club finished 11th and he lasted two months into the following season before his departure. His last managerial position was in Saudi Arabia where he lasted five months

Pros – his biggest advantage over the other potential candidates is his experience at managing at international level both in qualification and at tournament level having guided Croatia to both 2008 and 2012 European Championships. He is currently without employment so would be someone who would not demand additional compensation fee. The Croatian has good experience of managing high profile players and would be respected amongst the players

Cons – I am not sure he particularly wants the job…his agent had stated he would not apply but would talk to the SFA if they approached him. He has a lot of interest in him from big clubs with Celtic being linked with him over the last few days. Other than his record with Croatia he has a sketchy managerial record. I am not convinced that all of the Scottish supporters would be behind his appointment.



Gordon Strachan – although he has been a dark horse and not really seriously considered for the job his name has been mentioned with empathy around his departure. He started his career as a player manager for Coventry and managed to keep them in the Premier League in his first season. An 11th, 15th and 14th place finishes in subsequent seasons showed he was establishing himself as a stable top flight manager. Following departures of key players Coventry were relegated in 2001 and although started the season in the Championship he was sacked. He was soon to return to the Premier League with Southampton and at the time of appointment were written off as relegated but he managed to turn their fortunes round and they finished 11th. The following season they improved on that finish and ended in 8th and reached the FA Cup final and subsequently made Europe. In February 2004 he resigned as manager after a leak revealed he was going to leave at the end of the season. Following a break of a year and half he returned to management with Celtic during his tenure the club enjoyed a lot of successes with a League Cup, Scottish Cup and three League wins along with reaching the Champions League knockout phase twice. He spent 18 months at Middlesbrough which was a frustrating spell and tore up his contract and left the club. He is fondly remembered as Scotland manager and picked up the pieces of a disastrous World Cup qualification to finish in fourth place in the group. Euro 2016 qualification saw us miss out after an awful defeat in Georgia left us narrowly missing out. He also saw us narrowly miss out of qualification for a play-off place for the World Cup in 2018. He resigned from his role in the October of 2017 and not managed since.

Pros – he has done the job before so understands the pressures of the job and how international football works and what the SFA are like as employers. As Scotland manager we were close to qualification for major tournaments on two occasions. His departure from the job, although not a surprise, was met with some reservations and even more so in the time since he left his position. Currently not in employment perhaps another crack with the national team would appeal.

Cons – would the SFA reappoint a manager after what has happened with McLeish? I think that there is little to suggest that reappointing Strachan would result in any differences to the campaigns he was manager for. He had critics who said he was too loyal to some players and was stubborn in his squad selections. I don’t see the SFA repeating what they did with McLeish this time round. 


Darren Fletcher / Shaun Maloney- one for the romantics but could it actually happen. There was some media speculation around this about three weeks ago but was a quick to emerge as to disappear. Both have been superb professionals and have coaching badges. Shaun has been part of the coaching set-up with Belgium, ranked number one in the world currently. That being said it would be a huge risk for the boring and risk-free SFA to appoint these individually or a combination of these. The best we can hope is that they may be involved somewhere in the system.

Pros – both players have a wealth of international experience as a player and have been involved in the international set-up recently. Both are hugely respected as model professionals in the Scottish game and I think would be able to solve some of the issues around player’s choices around selection for the national team. I think the experiences both have had could make them good managers with Shaun being part of the Belgian national side coaching set up and Darren playing under the most successful manager in English football. Would be an interesting choice but a risk that could play off.

Cons – no managerial experience for either of the pair – Shaun Maloney is contracted to the Belgian national team in a coaching capacity and Darren Fletcher has not revealed any plans to retire from playing making him still eligible to play for Scotland. It would be a huge, uncharacteristic gamble from the SFA to appoint either or both of the pair to lead the National side and with Shaun being contracted elsewhere and Darren not looking at retirement at the time of this article being written it is a romantic non-starter.

Monday, 22 April 2019

March 2019 - Top 40

March 2019
Scotland Top 40
Each month I shall be assessing the national pool of players and looking at their merits for a place in the Scotland squad if I were given the dream job of managing Scotland. Performances when playing for Scotland will be the ultimate criteria that is looked at with performances for clubs also being monitored when Scotland are not in action.
As this is the first month of this the Top 40 for this month has been made up of players who are first and foremost fit for selection and not injured. From there I have looked at players who have performed well for Scotland in the recent past as the number one criteria and then looked at in form players for their respected club teams to make up the chart.
In order for the chart not to be imbalanced the first thirty-three places are made up of three starting elevens using the tactics and formation most likely to be used by Scotland going forward- the other seven places are made up by the best of the rest as it were.
With the promise of new players being involved in the Scotland squad and two squads being named for the upcoming friendlies next month’s chart should see changes that reflect the double header.

1-10 Scotland’s Safe bets
11-20 Best of the Rest
21-30 No surprises
31-40 Dark Horses
1 – Andrew Robertson (Caps 28, Goals 2)

A real fairy tale story of a player who was deemed not good enough by Celtic as a youngster, never gave up signed for Queens Park and due to him impressing where he has been (Dundee United and Hull) he is now a Liverpool regular, played in a Champions League final and is now Scotland captain – and deservedly so. Robertson always gives stand out performances for his country and is a consistent performer marauding down the left flank to support attacks. From wide areas he has a tremendous left foot and usually delivers excellent balls in for attacking players to thrive on. Defensively of late he has been examined more and has passed that test, showing that he is improving massively, being involved at Liverpool, playing in one of the elite leagues in the world regularly has pushed him on alongside European matches. All of which makes him a player who Scotland can build a team around for years to come.  
11 – Scott Bain (Caps 1, Goals 0)


Following the international retirement of Allan McGregor and the injury to Celtic team mate Craig Gordon it throws the door open to inexperienced keepers that have had to bide their time in appearing for Scotland – step forward Scott Bain. Having been involved in the squad a couple of times over the last few years he had to wait until the trip to Mexico last summer to earn his first cap where he performed admirably. As understudy to Craig Gordon he has also had to wait to get more game time for Celtic but since he has been involved he has performed well and when Gordon has been available he has kept his place in the team. In terms of selection for these opening games for the European Championship qualifying campaign it is looking like we will be starting the campaign with inexperience with the number 1 jersey and I feel that with his experience at Celtic he would be the best for the job.
21 – Liam Palmer (Caps 0, Goals 0)


With a lack of right back options for Scotland I feel that the Sheffield Wednesday full back could become a strong squad member for this campaign moving forward. With over 150 appearances in the Championship alongside being involved at international level at both Under 19 and 21 level I am surprised he has not been named in any previous squads let alone receive any caps. Defensively Palmer is very sound and is not renowned for marauding down the flank therefore meaning he has not scored many career goals or made many assists, a defender first and foremost. In terms of how he would fit in for Scotland in more challenging groups games where we may soak up pressure and look to attack he could be a very sound option if he can make the transition to international level. Looking at the different options we have in the right back department I feel that he must be on the radar of the Scottish management.
31 – Zander Clark (Caps 0, Goals 0)


Another goalkeeping option that could be explored by Scotland moving into this campaign. We have looked at keepers like Archer and McLaughlin and feel that Zander could push himself into contention for a place in the squad. Having not played for Scotland at any level and been farmed out to Elgin and Queen of the South the St Johnstone keeper has really pushed himself into the thoughts of the management team from absolutely nowhere. This season he has made some fantastic performances where he contributed to his team making five consecutive clean sheets and earned plaudits for his performance against Celtic. As previously mentioned it looks like we will be going into this campaign with inexperience in goal and finding keepers with the potential to be of international standard is going to take time however the way he has performed in the Scottish league means he must be in contention.
2 – James Forrest
(Caps 26, Goals 5)


Quite simply a player that has made himself one of the first name on the team sheet following his recent performances for Celtic but more importantly for Scotland. James was in danger of following other Scotland players before him in that he has not fulfilled his potential. However, his performances in Albania and in the vital win against Israel has changed that. In both games he was desperate for the ball and wanted to be involved in the play going forwards in a role that has given him more freedom that does not demand him to hog the touchline. His ability to ghost past players in the two previous matches has been a delight to watch and his goals, five in two matches, have shown that there is more to him than an outlet wide. If McLeish sticks with the tactics used in the last two games, and let’s be honest, why wouldn’t he James Forrest is absolutely pivotal in Scotland moving forward.
12 – Stephen O’Donnell (Caps 6 , Goals 0)

One of the finds of this campaign for me as he is a player who has come into the Scotland team very much from nowhere when we needed a right back he was the man called upon and has done a very commendable job. Going forward he has shown that he is a good out ball with his strength and height and during matches he has also shown that he is prepared to get forward to support the attack. At times in a Scotland shirt he has been targeted by opponents as an easy option and has shown good resolve and stood up to the challenge. Although he has made some errors he has not made anything catastrophic which would jeopardise his future going forward and brings a good balance to the side which others who have been deployed there have not always shown. At present he is the natural right back option but with two world class full backs in the squad he may not be the first choice right back moving forwards.
22 – Johnny Russell (Caps 9, Goals 0)


A player who has always been talked about for Scotland since his days of playing for Dundee United, Johnny Russell is another player who has been a beneficiary of players calling off and has impressed enough to be a regular in the squad during the Nations League campaign. He was initially involved as part of a striking partnership however following a change of tactics and fortunes he has found himself adding to his caps from the bench. Whenever he has played for Scotland he has looked very lively and always wanted the ball and look to attack with it. Moving forwards I can see him involved in squads but with the change of tactic being implemented may struggle for game time. Another factor around his international future could be where he is based domestically as I am certain McLeish and his staff find it more difficult to keep tabs on a player playing in America rather than in the UK or mainland Europe.
32 – Anthony Ralston (Caps 0, Goals 0)

At present we have an abundance of left sided defenders who could easily make a case to be included in the squad. However the same can not be said for the opposite flank where we look short in terms of options. In Celtic youngster Anthony Ralston we have a player who has only played ten senior matches for Celtic and been on loan at two clubs but has tasted Champions League football and been involved in the national squad at Under 19 and 21 level. Although this is far from ideal he has shown that he has potential to be a good right back moving forward for both club and country. Although he is not the bombarding modern day full back he is prepared to work a shift to get up and support attacking play, his best attribute is his no-nonsence style to defending and he has shown he enjoys the physical battle. A player who shone in the Toulon tournament in the summer for the U21s he has the potential to have a bright future.
3 – Ryan Fraser (Caps 6, Goals 1)


Without doubt one of the beneficiaries of the amount of call offs to the Scotland squad over the last few matches. The Bournemouth man was very much a squad member with a couple of caps to his name but not an integral part however his performances in the last two Nations League games have catapulted him into the thoughts of the Tartan Army and more importantly Alex McLeish. In the Albania game we saw what his club team see most weeks with him showing great energy and a high work rate throughout. He followed this performance up against Israel where again he buzzed with energy and was involved in all of the attacking play setting up Forrest for his opener. Added to that the obvious class he possesses (his goal against Albania and his link up play with the attacking players) makes him someone who will be very prominent in the thoughts of Scotland moving forward to the European qualification campaign.
13 – Craig Gordon (Caps 54, Goals 0)


Football can be about timing and taking opportunities that come along but there is always two sides to a story and for Craig Gordon he has found himself on the other side. Throughout his career he has shown that he is an incredible keeper having at one time been the record signing for a keeper in Britain. His ability has not diminished in that time and arguably his experiences for Scotland and in Europe for Celtic have made him better for it. However his career has been blighted by injuries and when he has been out of the picture both Allan McGregor and Scott Bain have stepped up to claim and retain the number one jerseys. With his experiences and his undoubted talent someone who can add competition to a squad. Gordon is an all-round competent keeper and has experience on his side. He is particularly strong with the ball at his feet and distribution. A very tough choice but a keeper I would involve as much as possible.
23 – Barry Bannan (Caps 27, Goals 0)


As managers come and go in positions it gives players fresh hope of forcing their way into managers plans. It also works in the opposite way where previous players who were in favour find themselves missing out and unfortunately for Barry Bannan the latter is the case currently. Under Gordon Strachan he was a mainstay in the squad and amassed the majority of his caps for his country but since then has not been involved. For me personally Bannan is a player who perhaps does not fit the formation being used currently as he is not a natural holding player, nor is he an attacking midfielder. But what he have is an incredibly skilled playmaker who can create opportunities. For me he needs to be involved more and with quality players we should be adapting formations to make them work in the team not let the formation dictate who we select and who we leave at home. For me he has to be involved more in this European Championship campaign.
33 – Oliver McBurnie (Caps 6, Goals 0)

Currently a player who is a bit of an enigma for Scotland as he has found the step up in level from English Championship to International level a challenge. When you look at his record and form domestically you would be hard pressed to argue against his inclusion in the squad and can see why he has been tried and tested but has not replicated his form having not found the net for Scotland and other than a handful of chances that spring to mind has not looked like doing so regularly in those games. As part of an attacking pair that McLeish had experimented with he was never played and although he is more suited to being a lone striker, as he does for Swansea, other players have been included ahead of him. When he has played for Scotland he has linked play well and impressed in the air but has looked very raw in the process. If he can continue to score goals will be hard to leave out of future camps.
4 – Scott McKenna (Caps 8, Goals 0)

Certainly a player who has made strides in his game at all levels to the point where his club will be tested again during the January transfer window having rejected a bid of £6 million for him in the summer. McKenna is a player who has grasped the opportunities given to him with both hands and now looks like the first choice centre back in the Scotland starting eleven. He looks the part for Scotland that is for sure – strong and dominating figure physically, he is great in the air and is quick across the ground. Added to that his distribution of the ball makes him a key figure for Scotland and it is easy to see why he is in demand at domestic level. From a personal perspective he is the best defender Scotland have and with his young age could easily be integral for Scotland for many campaigns to come. McLeish’s biggest headache will be finding a player who can partner him consistently for the European Championship qualifiers.
14 – John Souttar (Caps 3, Goals 0)

At the age of 22, Souttar has played over 150 senior games for Dundee United, Hearts and Scotland and added to that a prolonged spell of injury it shows how highly he is and has been thought of since he made his senior debut at just 17. Much touted to play for Scotland he has had to wait to make his debut in September this year where he has gone on to make three caps to date. In his caps he has not disgraced himself and has put himself in the shop window for a starting birth on a regular basis. Souttar possesses all of the attributes that could make him a Scotland regular he is very strong and good in the air with it he is a great reader of the game and covers the ground well which is something that Scotland have lacked over recent time. At his tender age he has a lot of experience at club level which he can call upon and has been pitted against good opposing strikers in that time. Certainly has a big future for Scotland when fit.
24 – Matt Phillips (Caps 14, Goals 1)

The West Brom player has had a very stop-start international career with Scotland having first made his international debut in 2012 to have only made 13 appearances in that time shows how patient he has had to be with his international career. From his perspective it seems like he has found a role within the squad which may have previously not been there as he has played as a lone striker effectively, particular recollections of his performance and goal in Hungary come to mind where he led the line well, worked tirelessly and kept possession of the ball. He has been incorporated into the squad for the Nations League and made appearances both against Albania and Israel from the bench where his energy and work rate impressed, particularly in the Albania game. He is someone who is clearly in McLeish’s thoughts and needs to keep making the most of the chances that come his way.
34 – Michael Devlin (Caps 0, Goals 0)

At present it seems like Scotland have a lot of different options in the centre of the defence and Aberdeen centre half Devlin is another player who McLeish likes the look of. He was named in the last squad from the outset but had to withdraw due to an injury which is likely to rule him out of his clubs League Cup final at the beginning of December. Where Devlin could gain an edge over rivals is that he partners Scott McKenna at club level and if they continue to forge a good defensive pairing, as they have done through this season, then there is no doubt they could replicate this at international level. Both players complement each other well this has been shown throughout this season domestically. He can easily secure himself a place in the squad moving forward but like so many others needs to grasp the chances that come his way as and when they do. Unfortunately injury has prevailed this thus far.
5 – Callum McGregor (Caps 9, Goals 0)

What a difference a couple of games can make to a player and his international status and Callum McGregor has certainly been the beneficiary of this following his performances against Israel and Albania. However to suggest his status in the national side is based on these games alone would be grossly unfair. His form for Celtic since the injury to former Scotland skipper Scott Brown has been superb and has even sparked debate about whether a previously indispensable player gets back into the Celtic team. McGregor is a very different player to the aforementioned and in possession will look to keep the ball moving and ensure that attacking play happens at a quick tempo or will be integral in ensuring this happens. Although he is yet to register for Scotland it is looking like a matter of time before it happens. Certainly will be a key player for the European Championship qualification campaign and beyond. 
15 – Charlie Mulgrew (Caps 39, Goals 3)

Even though Charlie Mulgrew has played in the third tier in England whilst representing Scotland he has shown that he is not only a good player to have in the squad but more than good enough to still be a key player for Scotland and had it not been for injuries would still be part of the central defenders starting games. Mulgrew has been another player who has shown versatility for Scotland over his 39 caps having played at left back and in the midfield he has found his role for both club and country as a central defender and helped give balance as he is naturally left footed. He has shown leadership and was present as a central defensive partner for both McKenna, Hendry and Souttar when they were first introduced at this level and his ability and experience supported them through. Although he will find it a challenge to make his way back into the starting line-up he is someone who should not be ruled out of making further appearances. 
25 – Oliver Burke (Caps 5, Goals 0)


I have to be honest and say that I feel for Oliver Burke in how his international career has begun but feel he could be about to have a renaissance. When he burst into contention he was performing regularly in the English Championship and looking good in doing so, catching the eye of many admirers to the point that at 19 he made a move to Germany for a huge sum. This led to him being considered to be the next star of Scottish football and was thrust into the team when he had little experience of international football at any other level. Since then he has played at Under 21 level and earned his stripes. He has moved back to British football and is currently enjoying his football at Celtic where he is making waves again, performing well, showing off his tremendous pace and scoring goals. All of which could make him a player who is included and heavily involved in the Scotland squad for this campaign. How he is managed is likely to be key.
35 – John Fleck (Caps 0, Goals 0)


Certainly a player who has forced himself on the radar of the Scotland management following the withdrawals of players from the last two Nations League matches. Fleck himself was a late call up to the squad, so much so that he was not involved in the squad against Albania but appeared on the bench against Israel. Supporters of the Scottish game and those looking out for talent coming through would be aware of Fleck and what he managed to achieve personally at Rangers but since then has quietly and unassumingly continued his development. Now at Sheffield United he has made himself a regular in the team. It has not all been plain sailing for Fleck who found himself playing in the lower leagues in England until recently. He is a player whose main attributes are to break play and keep the ball appose to attacking. Could be involved in the European campaign – feel he would need to benefit from injuries for this to happen.
6 – John McGinn (Caps 13, Goals 0)


Although not involved in the last games of the Nations League, McGinn would be the only other change I would make to the starting eleven and would throw him straight back into the engine room for Scotland to add more balance that may be needed moving forward. Against Israel in particular we looked like we were lacking a destructive player who could break up and close down play. Both Israel goals came from shots outside the box where we were too slow to react and I see John McGinn being a player who can have a huge future for Scotland by playing that role whilst being a driving force creating chances as well – which we will need against stronger opponents. He has shown for Scotland he has can do that marking Christian Eriksen out of a game on his debut and his ability to create and score goals has also been seen initially at Hibs but now for Aston Villa where he has established himself as a first team regular.
16 – Tom Cairney (Caps 2, Goals 0)


Frustratingly, we seem to have a player who on face value has not decided on whether to commit to Scotland or to wait on his options and see whether England pursue him. Cairney has been involved in Scotland squads but because he has not been capped in a competitive match, makes him eligible for England. Do Scotland need him? Arguably not, if we look at the last few matches and consider players who have been left on the bench or injured, however he is a very creative player who for three seasons he has been Fulham’s stand out player and is now playing for them in the Premier League. McLeish and his backroom staff need to be pushing him for a decision before the next campaign begins so it can be addressed and either move forward with him or not. If he were to commit to Scotland then he would add welcome competition and I feel would be a player who can be instrumental moving forwards.
26 – Robert Snodgrass (Caps 26 , Goals 7)

It is an interesting time for Robert Snodgrass and he finds himself at a crossroad with his international future. Some decisions he needs to make and some will fall on the management. During the Nations League he had asked not be considered for selection but had stressed he has not retired from internationals. Moving into the next campaign he will probably review this situation for a permanent solution. If he retires we lose a good player who is good enough to be in the squad but also to challenge for a starting birth. If he decides to make himself available then it will be down to the management team to decide whether a player can pick and choose his availability. Whatever the outcome Snodgrass is one of those players who can create chances with his range of passes and vision. Added to that he is a goal threat and someone who previously for Scotland has been a solid, consistent performer – over to you now Mr Snodgrass.
36 – David Marshall (Caps 27, Goals 0)


Although he is a keeper who has not made a Scotland squad under McLeish for me he is still good enough to be involved and included in the squad and could add further competition to both Craig Gordon and current number one Allan McGregor. Under Strachan he was our first choice stopper for the majority of his tenure and now is not involved at all. He is still playing at a high level in the English Championship and has been a consistent performer in a struggling side. Add to that his international experience and I would be having him in the squad when available. One of the downsides to Marshall is that he is coming to the end of his career and perhaps he is being overlooked with an eye on the future and giving other keepers a chance to meet up with the squad and force their way into the reckoning. However I still feel that as a player who has never let his country down and the form he is in deserves to be considered still.
7 – Kieran Tierney (Caps 12, Goals 0)


Looking at the starting eleven from both the Albania and Israel making changes could be deemed harsh, however Kieran Tierney would add to the team, even if it means playing out of position. Having been the best left back in the Scottish domestic game at least three seasons ironically he is not be the first choice in this position for his country. However leaving him out of the starting eleven is absurd and Scotland have tried to incorporate him into the team at both right back and centre back – neither of which are ideal however I think to get the best of this situation Tierney needs to be switching flanks at international level. The Celtic full back is one who loves a physical challenge and is a defender first and foremost, but he is improving his support play when teams attack. His energy, drive and overall quality is what Scotland need and although it is not ideal playing Tierney out of position is better than not playing him at all.
17 – Stuart Armstrong (Caps 11, Goals 1)

Another player who has been on the periphery of the starting eleven for Scotland for a while and has had to wait for a chance to impress. However in the last two Nations League matches he was given that starting in both games, however more telling perhaps was that he was withdrawn in both matches possibly showing that currently he has not done enough to cement his place in the starting eleven. He is a player with undisputed quality making him a summer signing for Southampton however this move has been tough as he is finding game time hard to come across currently. An on form Armstrong is a creative player who is a driving force in leading attacks and this was seen in glimpses for Scotland recently, particularly the Israel game however he is one that needs more first team football to build his confidence. Certainly has potential to be a key figure for Scotland is he can regain form and match sharpness.
27 – Christophe Berra (Caps 41, Goals 4)

Like his Hearts team mate Steven Naismith, Berra found himself not only in form for his club but playing for his country regularly again before injury struck and now finds his recovery further hampered by other players (Bates, McKenna and Souttar) taking opportunities presented to them that could harm his international place. Berra has been a tremendous asset for Scotland - excellent in the air and has contributed to goals from set pieces in this manner but has also shown he is a great reader of the game and enjoys the physical side of it also. Scotland need Berra back playing and regularly to give McLeish some thought provoking decisions around the team. Although at the latter stages of his career it is certain that if he bounces back from this injury set back and plays to the level he was at prior he will be back in the hunt for future caps. His experience would benefit some of the younger players coming through.
37 – Lewis Morgan (Caps 2, Goals 0)


Celtic youngster Lewis Morgan is a much anticipated future Scotland regular and had this first taste of senior international football on the Americas tour in which he was one of the positives to come from a much maligned end of season tour. In both appearances he was eager and showed a very good work rate. Always busy on the ball his first thought was to always encourage Scotland moving forward into the final third this was primarily done through his talents of dribbling with the ball and wanting to take players on. At present he is finding game time hard to come across at Celtic but through biding his time and making them most of chances he gets when he does appear he can follow in the footsteps of McGregor and Christie and breakthrough for both club and country. Certainly a player with a strong future at international level if the trajectory he finds himself on continues just may not be for the European qualifiers.
8 – Ryan Christie (Caps 5, Goals 0)


Over recent months Ryan Christie has made unrecognisable changes in his form that takes him from being a bit part player at Celtic to being a first team regular for both club and now surely for country. Due to the depleted squad for the Albania game he was named in the starting eleven, which with a full strength squad would not have happened. However he took his chance to impress superbly well and even though his club mate James Forrest will take the plaudits I felt he was the best player on the park against Albania. His work rate is phenomenal, this is epitomised with his contribution to the first goal in Albania winning the ball to set up the goal. He has tenacity and likes a tackle but is very creative and was involved in the majority of Scotland’s attacking play. If he can continue to keep his place for his side and show the current form over a time he will become a Scotland regular for years to come.  
18 – Callum Paterson (Caps 11, Goals 0)

If Paterson had remained a right back where he first made his name I am certain he would have more caps for Scotland. However he has transformed his game into being an attacking midfielder and often used as a striker for Cardiff in the Premier League. For Scotland however this is a fiercely competitive and on the odd occasion he has played there has not done enough to make himself a headache for McLeish. In the last two Nations League matches he reverted back to playing at right back to fix a problem and although he did okay he did not show enough to make him look like he will guarantee that spot either. Against better opponents they would have exploited that further and we may have been looking at different results. His form for club and versatility make him someone who is a good asset to the National squad but needs to make more of opportunities that come his way to force his way in to the team.
28 – Liam Cooper (Caps 0, Goals 0)


Of all the players eligible for Scotland it remains a mystery to me why Liam Cooper has not been included in more squads and capped at this level. Looking at his form and credentials I am not sure what more he can do as an individual as well. Cooper is obviously on the radar of the national side as he has been involved in squads but has not converted this to caps. The centre half and captain is a regular in the Leeds squad that are flying in the Championship and has been consistently involved for his club for three seasons now. As a defender he is a typical ‘no nonsense’ defender who loves a challenge. Cooper has all of the attributes to be successful domestically and internationally but needs a break in the side and I am confident if this were to happen he would be a regular. My concern for him is that with all the different options tried and tested there in recent games does the management team rate him to do the job?
38 – Lewis Stevenson (Caps 1, Goals 0)

Although Hibernian left-back will go down as a club legend it is clear that he will be someone who may not ever gain more than his solitary one. This is certainly not down to a lack of ability, had Stevenson been involved pre Robertson and Tierney I am sure he would have been a regular in the squad at least with more caps to his name and if called upon in the future would be a good option. As a defender he is strong, reliable and a great reader of the game always consistent in his attributes defensively. Offensively he is a player who likes to get forward and does not need much encouragement to do so. Any player that can play for the same club over the time he has, under different managers and systems and still be the first name on the team sheet shows how valuable and highly thought of he is. I personally would love to see him, and think he is good enough to be involved more for Scotland but faces very stiff competition.
9 – David Bates (Caps 2, Goals 0)


If I were to name my next starting eleven the young former Rangers centre half would make my starting eleven. This is because he did not put a foot wrong in his debut against Albania or against Israel in his home bow, however he has a lot of competition from players who will be chomping at the bit to get back in the team. It is now a test of character for Bates to keep his shirt and for me he does that with performances like he has put in so far. It is very early days but so far he looks at home at this level showing he is very good in the air and a good reader of the game but he also adds some much needed pace in the defence which is something that Scotland sides have often been undone by. We have to consider that his two games have hardly been against world beating sides but at this early stage he looks like a player who has been given a chance to impress and can carve a long and successful international career from it.
19 – Gary Mackay-Steven (Caps 2, Goals 0)

With only a couple of cameo appearances so far for Scotland his ranking may come as a surprise however for me he is in the form of his career at club level and this has been recognised by Alex McLeish who has involved him in the last few squads. Similar to former team mate James Forrest he has adjusted his game away from a wide man who hogs the touch line and tries to deliver crosses to being someone who will come inside, want the ball and then damage defenders by running at  them. He has been involved in goals and assists for Aberdeen this season and his inclusion in the squads are justified. He needs to now begin to make the most of any opportunities that come his way internationally as well as keeping up the high quality of form he is showing domestically because he faces a lot of competition for a place in the midfield. If given game time all he can do is impress to keep him in the thoughts of the management.
29 – Matt Ritchie (Caps 16, Goals 3)


Another player who follows a small and bizarre trend in the squad of players who have made themselves unavailable for a period of time to Scotland without ending their careers permanently however this decision could have done this for him anyway. Looking at the Scotland squad and performances especially in the last two games he has not been missed particularly. In form and on his game he has shown ability and class to influence games at international level in the same way he has at times lit up the Premier League. However the fact remains that Scotland need to have committed players it is the only way Scotland will build on the recent successes of the Nations League promotion. From a personal perspective I feel that if he commits to the cause then he can be part of the squad and break into the starting eleven as he did under Strachan but unfortunately for Alex McLeish and Scotland at the moment it is all ifs and buts.
39 – Ryan Jack (Caps 2, Goals 0)


Ryan Jack has been involved for Scotland but has not necessarily been shown in his best light by being played at right back on his debut and making a late substitution appearance to date. Added to that his injuries that have restricted his appearances at club level and we have a player who has potential to be a success at this level but a present is not someone we can rely on confidently. Now playing under one of the best midfielders of his generation at club level his manager is a fan and believes he is good enough to be in the Scotland squad and add to his caps but needs a run in the Rangers team and an opportunity to force his way in at international level to prove this. Although competition in the middle of the park is not as strong as it previously had been there are players ahead of him in the pecking order. A good run domestically with high levels of performance and he will attract the attention of the Scotland manager for sure.
10 – Steven Fletcher (Caps 33, Goals 10)


From international outcast a player who is likely to start with up front as we begin our European campaign. Fletcher is another player who has benefitted greatly from the call offs of late. Now it is down to him to stay fit, find goals at club level to take him into the next international fixtures brimming with confidence. Critics will always have negative comments about Fletcher, who has found the net on ten occasions for his country (six of which against Gibraltar), however his performance against Israel was absolutely superb and was a shout for me as Man of the Match. His hold up play was text book as he linked the play between him as a lone striker and the supporting midfield. For a target man there is so much more to him than the stereotypes. He has a good touch, great feet and his work rate is always unquestioned. There may be better natural finishers available however in the system we are playing not many better for the role.
20 – Scott McTominay (Caps 5, Goals 0)

Over the years Scotland have had players that burst onto the scene and too much pressure is put on them and they don’t reach their potential (Oliver Burke, Ryan Gauld etc.) and in Scott McTominay we have a player who is undoubtedly a special talent – you don’t make Manchester United’s match day squad consistently if you are not. However we need to remember that he plays with arguably better players than we have at our disposal at club level so making him a focal point is expecting too much. In his appearances for Scotland he has looked very composed on the ball and retention of the ball is key to his game. He has not shown a great deal going forwards and is not a typical holding or defensive midfielder who can break up play from what we have seen. That being said he is a big talent for the future and feel that he will be involved for Scotland for a long time but needs to find his feet at this level first before that can happen.
30 - Barry Douglas (Caps 1, Goals 0)


Barry Douglas will probably look back at the end of his career and feel hard done by at the sheer volume of left backs that Scotland have at their disposal because for me is a player who is good enough to be involved in the squad and add competition to it whilst adding to his solitary cap. Currently playing in the Championship at Leeds he has been a very consistent performer for them following on from his time at Wolves in which he helped them get promotion to the top flight in England. Douglas, unlike the majority of Scottish players, has also spent time abroad and has therefore tasted different experiences which are valuable in the game. Always a reliable option and a throwback to an old fashioned left back wanting to defend first and supporting attacks second. Unfortunately for him he has two world class players ahead of him in the pecking order as well as other options that have been looked at which is unfortunate for him.
40 – Graeme Shinnie (Caps 5, Goals 0)


Most sides have players who are versatile and the Aberdeen skipper has certainly been for Scotland having operated both as a left back and in the Scottish engine room. Shinnie is another who has had to bide his time to be involved at international level having impressed his clubs supporters and at domestic level for a prolonged period of time. He is another who needs to grasp opportunities that come his way and so far has done that when he has played for Scotland. This will be key in keeping his place in the squad. Although I struggle to see how he will break into the starting eleven there is no doubt that his versatility makes him someone of value in the squad. Being able to operate in more than one position gives McLeish options and in Shinnie you will get someone who is as honest as they come, breaks play up and always looks to retain the ball – not always pretty but definitely necessary.