Thursday, 16 May 2019

We all think we know who it will be...but who are the other candidates for the top job


Ten Scotland Managerial candidates that may be in line for the top job

It has been just under a month since Alex McLeish was ‘relieved’ of this duties as Scotland manager and since then a lot of names and speculation have been cast over the next man for the job. In seemingly characteristic fashion the SFA have allowed this to happen and have dithered around who the next boss will be. However over the last two days the resolution has begun with strong rumours of an appointment being made tomorrow. It was revealed around two and a half weeks ago that a ‘shortlist’ had been discussed and finalised…with that in mind I am not sure what has taken so long. Let’s hope that the time taken is to ensure the right man is selected. Below, this article focuses on the Top 10 candidates, in order, on who I would be approaching as Scotland manager.


Steve Clarke – currently the nation’s choice it seems. He has spent a lot of time working in good managerial teams with Jose Mourinho, Kenny Dalglish and Avram Grant. He then took on the top job of West Bromwich Albion and spent a full season and a third of a season in charge their in the Premier League where he managed to stabalise the team as an established top flight team.  Following his spell at West Bromwich he had an ill-feted stint at Reading before assisting at Aston Villa. It is at Kilmarnock, where he has been since October 2017 that has caught the eye of clubs and made him a strong candidate for Scotland. At the time of publishing this he is the bookies favourite with odds as low as 1/10 for him to land the job.


Pros – he has the support of a lot of Scotland fans and media alike. This is because he has taken a side with limited resources and made them a difficult team to beat and raised their expectations and standards in the process. Clarke took over with Kilmarnock languishing near the foot of the table and has taken them to being on the verge of European football. His contract runs until the end of the season and he has not refused to directly rule out the job when questioned.

Cons – he has repeatedly stated that Kilmarnock was not a forever job as he has family commitments in London and is missing his grandchildren for example – would this job help or hinder that? Attraction from clubs in England could sway him back down where he would be involved every day in the running of a club. More recently his condemnation of a referee in a domestic game may not have gone down too well and may be ill-timed if he has desired on the top job in Scotland.


Derek McInnes – initially a stong candidate in the eyes of the supporters and media along with the bookmakers but all three of those listed have cooled a little on him. Having started his managerial career at St Johnstone where he guided them to the Premiership before leaving for an unsuccessful spell in England with Bristol City. It is in his current job at Aberdeen where he has really made a name for himself. In his six year spell to date he has won the League Cup, finished runners up on three occasions, guided the club back into Europe and generally made Aberdeen a very good and stable side.

Pros – he has transformed a side from being a mid-table mediocre side into regular challengers to Celtic for silverware in Scotland. His teams are usually well organised and is not afraid to turn to youth, an area where Scotland have a lot of potential players coming through.. He has recently stated that the plan is to manage Scotland at some point in his career…

Cons - …that may not be now. He is still deemed a young manager and perhaps is not interested in the Scotland job at the moment, although he is considered a strong candidate, his vice chairman has stated that he would not accept the job yet With the plans for a new stadium and training facilities at Aberdeen on the horizon, he could be tempted to stay longer in order to close the gap on the Old Firm more if he possibly can.


David Moyes – a manager who has been touted for the Scotland job since it became vacant and although perhaps not seen as one of the fans choices his credentials and experiences are hard to match again the other serious candidates for the position. At the age of 22 he had started his route into coaching by taking coaching badges and his first job came at Preston where he initially saved them from relegation within two season they had been promoted and narrowly missed out on a second promotion. He then moved on to Everton, where he enjoyed the most success as a manager and helped him raise his profile. After eleven years at one club, leading them to a fourth place finish and European football both in Champions League qualification and Europa League, he took on what now seems to have been the poison chalice of taking over from fellow Scotsman Sir Alex Ferguson at Manchester United. Although his record at the time was not the most impressive and certainly did not match his predecessor in any way, within 18 months he was sacked. This move now looks hasty and the next managers all have worse or comparable records to Sir Alex. His more recent record does not look good on his CV – sacked by Real Sociedad and resigned from both Sunderland and West Ham with poor win records at all three clubs – since then he has been out of work but with his experiences could be a good fit. 

Pros – a lot of experience in many different aspects of football – he has managed elite players, managed abroad and in European club competition. He has the respect of professional footballers and is someone who a lot of the ‘stay away’ players may come and play for (a huge barrier to McLeish’s tenure). His sides are usually difficult to beat and organises his teams very well. He is currently out of a job so compensation would not be an issue for the frugal SFA.

Cons – recently, like other candidates mentioned, he has said that he would prefer a move back to club football and rumours of him managing Celtic do not appear to be going away. Having managed big clubs in England I am not sure his wage demands would be something that the SFA would be prepared to meet either. His recent managerial record is also not one that would inspire the nation potentially and his style of football may make Scotland even more difficult to watch.


Neil Lennon – Lennon has spent the majority of his managerial career in Scotland and has enjoyed a lot of his personal successes there. Initially he was appointed as Celtic reserve’s team but following a successful caretaker role he was given the first team managers job. During his four years at the club he led the Glasgow side to the Scottish Cup twice and the League on three occasions. At the end of four years he moved to Bolton where he spent a frustrating season and a half where they battled relegation and suffered with cash problems. His next job was back in Scotland, with Hibernian. During his time there he led them to promotion to the Scottish Premier League and to Europa League football. He was suspended in January 2019 and left the club by mutual consent. Less than a month later he was back as interim manager of Celtic where he has overseen the club win the league, Scottish League Cup and are a game away from the treble Treble. Know the Scottish game well and would be a strong candidate.

Pros – his experience and successes in the Scottish game is probably paramount to the other names mentioned. His current contract with Celtic runs until the end of the season with no word yet on an extension or whether he will even be retained means that he could be a free agent in time prior to the next European Championship qualifying matches. He has managed a lot of good players in his time and has made Celtic in his time there and Hibernian good sides and his knowledge of Scottish football and players is very strong also.

Cons - whether Celtic sign him or not he will be a man in demand and he will have options. Lennon will need to consider whether the day to day running of club football can be substituted for international management. My general feeling is that he would be lured to the day to day work somewhere, most probably in England. His involvement with Celtic and Hibernian may make him someone who struggles to win over all supporters.


Scot Gemmill – perhaps not the first name that sprung to people’s minds when choosing a Scotland manager but it would be a move that follows the successes of England and Germany with appointing within (both Gareth Southgate and Joachim Low were working at international level before landing the top job). Although his managerial experience has been limited by only managing Scotland at Under 17 and 21 level. He is well respected by the SFA and could be ready for the job if the SFA do gamble on him.

Pros – biggest pro for Scot Gemmill is that he is in the system and on the pay role currently. He knows what his employers are like and has a good working relationship with them. Looking enviably at relative successes England have had it is clear that like Southgate, Gemmill knows the players available very well having worked within the system since 2014. He is a young manager with fresh ideas and Scotland have also previously appointed within when Craig Brown and Andy Roxburgh were given the job.

Cons – I think the next Scotland appointment is one that could either help or hinder the perception of the SFA amongst Scotland supporters. Over recent history they have failed to be seen in a positive light and a lot of the anger from the San Marino game was aimed at them. Addressing this would be to perhaps give in to public demand a bit and appoint one of the front runners. I am not sure Gemmill’s appointment would be well supported amongst Scotland fans and he would already be on the back foot trying to win them over. His lack of experience outside the Scotland system may also go against him as he doesn’t have the experience of dealing with players and clubs like he would have to with the job in question.



Malky Mackay – again, another name that has immediately been linked with the job and has led Scotland on a caretaker basis. He started his career when he took on the Watford job toward the end of the 2008-09 season. He then completed the following season in the Championship before Cardiff offered him a three year deal after compensation for his services were agreed. His spell there was very successful with a League Cup final and promotion to the Premier League. In the December of the following season he had been sacked by the club. Following his sacked alleged leaked messages and communication sent from Mackay came to the forefront which were homophobic, sexist and racist- it meant his reputation had been tarnished. His next appointment at Wigan was met with huge opposition and within five months he was dismissed – a very controversial choice if he were to be given the Scotland job.

Pros – he is another potential candidate who is employed by the SFA at the moment so understands how they work as employers. He has tasted international management, albeit it briefly, when he took charge of Scotland in a friendly match against Holland prior to Alex McLeish’s appointment. He would be a person who understands the talent pool that is available for Scotland as current performance director.

Cons – his departure from Cardiff has had damaging effects to his career and if he were to be given the Scotland national team role it would be very controversial and I am not sure the SFA would want to have to deal with the fallout from it. With a lack of coaching and management over the last few years and how quickly the game evolves perhaps this job would also be a leap too far.


Jack Ross – would be a real fairytale for the current Sunderland manager. Having played his football predominantly in Scotland and not achieving full honours as a player (capped at B level) to go onto take the national team job would be testament to his work ethic. Having been a coach and interim manager at Dumbarton he moved onto the Hearts coaching team but his first management role was at Alloa where he impressed, his tenure there lead to St Mirren calling where he stabilised the club in the Championship before getting the Paisley club promotion to the Scottish Premier League. In May 2018 he was given permission to talk to Sunderland where he has led them to a playoff place in League One. His successes at St Mirren and Hearts, as well as being a younger manager with fresh ideas have led him to be considered a candidate for Scotland. 

Pros – young, fresh manager with new coaching ideas (both Strachan and McLeish were criticised for being ‘out of touch’. He has been very open and honest and stated that he wants to manage Scotland at some point in his career.

Cons – that point in his career may not be now. He has stated recently that he has unfinished business at Sunderland and the draw of them being in the Championship (if they negotiate the playoffs) may be too difficult to turn down. I think he is a definite candidate for the job but would need others to decline it first.



Slavan Bilic – around two/three weeks ago speculation was high around Bilic, however this seems to have cooled. His first management involvement was with his national team during Euro 2008 qualification he led Croatia to topping their group which included England. At the tournament itself. Having failed to qualify for the World Cup in 2010 they did qualify for the European Championships in 2012 in which they were drawn in a tough group and did not make it out of the group stage – this led to his departure and he is held in high esteem within Croatia for his achievements. Subsequent appointments have not gone as well, Lokomotiv Moscow sacked him after 18 months with his tenure seeing the side finish in their worst league position. A short spell in Turkey with Besiktas did not end much better. West Ham was his next move and he performed very well and showed why he was seen to be a good manager – West Ham finished the 2007-08 season in 7th and broke a lot of club records in doing so helping them qualify for Europe. 2016-17 the club finished 11th and he lasted two months into the following season before his departure. His last managerial position was in Saudi Arabia where he lasted five months

Pros – his biggest advantage over the other potential candidates is his experience at managing at international level both in qualification and at tournament level having guided Croatia to both 2008 and 2012 European Championships. He is currently without employment so would be someone who would not demand additional compensation fee. The Croatian has good experience of managing high profile players and would be respected amongst the players

Cons – I am not sure he particularly wants the job…his agent had stated he would not apply but would talk to the SFA if they approached him. He has a lot of interest in him from big clubs with Celtic being linked with him over the last few days. Other than his record with Croatia he has a sketchy managerial record. I am not convinced that all of the Scottish supporters would be behind his appointment.



Gordon Strachan – although he has been a dark horse and not really seriously considered for the job his name has been mentioned with empathy around his departure. He started his career as a player manager for Coventry and managed to keep them in the Premier League in his first season. An 11th, 15th and 14th place finishes in subsequent seasons showed he was establishing himself as a stable top flight manager. Following departures of key players Coventry were relegated in 2001 and although started the season in the Championship he was sacked. He was soon to return to the Premier League with Southampton and at the time of appointment were written off as relegated but he managed to turn their fortunes round and they finished 11th. The following season they improved on that finish and ended in 8th and reached the FA Cup final and subsequently made Europe. In February 2004 he resigned as manager after a leak revealed he was going to leave at the end of the season. Following a break of a year and half he returned to management with Celtic during his tenure the club enjoyed a lot of successes with a League Cup, Scottish Cup and three League wins along with reaching the Champions League knockout phase twice. He spent 18 months at Middlesbrough which was a frustrating spell and tore up his contract and left the club. He is fondly remembered as Scotland manager and picked up the pieces of a disastrous World Cup qualification to finish in fourth place in the group. Euro 2016 qualification saw us miss out after an awful defeat in Georgia left us narrowly missing out. He also saw us narrowly miss out of qualification for a play-off place for the World Cup in 2018. He resigned from his role in the October of 2017 and not managed since.

Pros – he has done the job before so understands the pressures of the job and how international football works and what the SFA are like as employers. As Scotland manager we were close to qualification for major tournaments on two occasions. His departure from the job, although not a surprise, was met with some reservations and even more so in the time since he left his position. Currently not in employment perhaps another crack with the national team would appeal.

Cons – would the SFA reappoint a manager after what has happened with McLeish? I think that there is little to suggest that reappointing Strachan would result in any differences to the campaigns he was manager for. He had critics who said he was too loyal to some players and was stubborn in his squad selections. I don’t see the SFA repeating what they did with McLeish this time round. 


Darren Fletcher / Shaun Maloney- one for the romantics but could it actually happen. There was some media speculation around this about three weeks ago but was a quick to emerge as to disappear. Both have been superb professionals and have coaching badges. Shaun has been part of the coaching set-up with Belgium, ranked number one in the world currently. That being said it would be a huge risk for the boring and risk-free SFA to appoint these individually or a combination of these. The best we can hope is that they may be involved somewhere in the system.

Pros – both players have a wealth of international experience as a player and have been involved in the international set-up recently. Both are hugely respected as model professionals in the Scottish game and I think would be able to solve some of the issues around player’s choices around selection for the national team. I think the experiences both have had could make them good managers with Shaun being part of the Belgian national side coaching set up and Darren playing under the most successful manager in English football. Would be an interesting choice but a risk that could play off.

Cons – no managerial experience for either of the pair – Shaun Maloney is contracted to the Belgian national team in a coaching capacity and Darren Fletcher has not revealed any plans to retire from playing making him still eligible to play for Scotland. It would be a huge, uncharacteristic gamble from the SFA to appoint either or both of the pair to lead the National side and with Shaun being contracted elsewhere and Darren not looking at retirement at the time of this article being written it is a romantic non-starter.

No comments:

Post a Comment